The Paper Mill Store

4.9 / 5

The Paper Mill Store

4.9 Great
The main metric, showing how trustworthy is the business. Calculated using proprietary rating algorithm based on the AI, analyzing 25 different parameters.

4.9 / 5

Trust Score

4.9

Reviews

5

Social

5

Featured

5

Technical

Is thepapermillstore.com legit?

  • Many trusted websites are linking to this site
  • The site has mostly good reviews
  • The EV SSL certificate is valid
  • This website has existed for more than 3 years
  • Facebook account found with large audience
  • Linkedin account found with large audience
  • Instagram account not found
  • Business not mentioned on Wikipedia
  • Pinterest account not found
  • Twitter account not found
  • Youtube account not found
We check all genuine customer reviews and show the number of approved and rejected reviews. All fake or false reviews are excluded from the Reviews Score.

Reviews Analysis

27

reviews

vs

0

AI declined reviews

0%

NON VALIDATED REVIEWS

You have to be an authorized business owner in order to use this feature.

Based on 28 reviews

Smart.Reviews

4.9

27 reviews

Sitejabber

5

1 reviews

Thepapermillstore.com Review

Buy paper card stock envelopes more from top paper mills at The Paper Mill Store Save money with rewards discounts with free shipping available

Thepapermillstore.com Customer Service Contacts

No contact details for this company.

Last update: Fri, Feb 9, 2024 4:01 PM

Write a review

Point: Great

Review thepapermillstore.com

Photos of you review

*Supported files .jpg, .gif, .png, .webp

Thepapermillstore.com Reviews & Complaints (27)

Filter reviews by tags

delivery 5 /5

price 5 /5

quality 5 /5

customer service 5 /5

on-time

I don't have a problem with the product, but the customer service is extremely poor, or should I say 'rude".

I ordered envelopes for a mailer that needed to go out immediately, so it made sense to use expedited shipping. The order total was $155.00, shipping $75.00. The envelopes finally arrived well after the time when they could be used, so we used what we had on hand. Although I opted not to return the shipment, I did request that my card be credited for the expedited shipping costs.

This request was refused, rudely. There many other options available for purchasing paper and envelopes. I will not use the Paper Mill Store again
1

2 years ago

review by elizabethgr

Your website is very easy to navigate and has an excellent selection of products. The ordering process was smooth, and I received confirmation of my order right away, along with shipping updates which are much appreciated.
5

3 years ago

review by Susan V.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I found your website easy to use. I didn't have any trouble finding 100% recycled paper, whereas other stores don't make this information very clear. Communication was very good and the items arrived securely packaged.
5

3 years ago

review by Lisa U.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

Great information in regard to types of paper. I was able to read and watch videos to ensure what I was ordering would meet my needs. Ordering was simple and quick, and my items arrived in a timely manner. Great Experience shopping with The Paper Mill Store. I will continue to do business with them to help with my paper needs.
5

3 years ago

review by Cathy T.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

Sample books I purchased from Paper Mill was exactly what I needed! Before making actual paper purchases, I wanted to see samples and looked for one-stop-shop for options. It was great Paper Mill had lots of samples books with very reasonable price. Delivery was fast, and I got what I ordered. After exploring these samples books, I will definitely use this site to make paper purchase.
5

3 years ago

review by Bri R.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I love all the options to narrow my search down further. Makes it easy to find just what I'm looking for (I've looked at a lot of websites, and this one is definitely the most customer-friendly and focused). One suggestion for improvement: Please offer more choices on high quality large size white colored paper that is not watermarked. I wanted to order something similar to 28 x 36 inch paper and cut it down to 7 x 9 for paper planners that I produce. But I can't find anything that isn't watermarked. Watermarked pages would look funny in a planner. I finally ended up making the planners 8.5 x 5.5 (by cutting letter size paper in half), since this is one of the few options you have that isn't watermarked.
5

3 years ago

review by Vandana C.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I had a great experience purchasing from the Paper Mill Store. The customer service was good and easy to work with. Their products were exactly what I expected based on the information given. Good quality, nice paper.
5

3 years ago

review by Anna I.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

We have been using The Paper Mill Store for a few years now and love the products. I like that you can purchase sample packs before buying a whole ream of material. The custom services are a must for us. The scoring makes our lives so much better.
5

3 years ago

review by Robertajo Q.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I was happy with my shopping experience but when my package arrived I was over the top. My paper was in a very sturdy box and had lots of bubble wrap all around the paper!!!! Each ream was pristine. Congrats to the shipping department!!
5

3 years ago

review by Joanie Y.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

Paper Mill Store was very competitively priced! I was a little weary at first because I was buying online and couldn't see the actual product, but the paper was perfect! Don't waste your time at the fancy stores that charge 3x the price.
5

3 years ago

review by Ariel L.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

The PaperMill Store has a fantastic selection at an affordable price. Finding 80 lb parchment paper at this price was a wonderful gift. Thank you so much! When I need paper again, I will definitely shop here first!
5

3 years ago

review by Signe E.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I continually purchase this specific stock for all of my clients' invitation and event needs. Paper Mill Store offers the best pricing and provides fast shipping, or alerts to me when the stock is available to ship so I can plan ahead for my printing. More than happy with the service provided by PMS!
5

3 years ago

review by Jill U.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I love the Paper Mill Store for several reasons: (1) website ease of use, (2) stock is always there when I need it, in the quantity I need, (3) fast shipping (and packaging is nice - thick box to package the boxes of envelopes - less envelope corners get squished), (4) and, of course, the products are great and high quality!
5

3 years ago

review by Leslie S.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I have been looking for a very specific texture and weight of vellum paper and The Paper Mill Store made this process very easy by offering sample purchases. My samples came packaged with clearly identified product information sheet, but without labels so I could test out printing. Purchasing paper online can be tricky (especially when you're looking for paper that is translucent) and TPMS was super helpful!
5

3 years ago

review by Alexandra I.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

Our office purchases envelopes from Papermill. We have purchased multiples over several years, we get what we order and on time. Their website is easy to use and reordering is very simple. Highly recommend Papermill!
5

3 years ago

review by Ernest X.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

The Papermillstore has great prices on a wide selection of papers. When I order from them I know the paper will arrive in perfect condition - thoughtfully packaged and no reams that are broken open. They send first quality product fast and well packaged - what more could you want?
5

3 years ago

review by Mark U.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

The Paper Mill Store is great. They offer so many papers and ship orders promptly and the best secured bubble wrapped box I have received in a long time. This is important when shipping paper so the corners do not get dinged. You can tell they care about quality!
5

3 years ago

review by Cindy S.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

Referred by my graphic designer, I am ordering stock for my small company. Your papers give me a high end professional image. Product received yesterday afternoon, I opened the case to insure all was delivered. No comment on the stock as yet, I haven't used any of it, haven't run it though my printer to see how well it performs. Thanks for the ease of interaction so far.
5

3 years ago

review by Belva L.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

The quality paper products I buy from The Papermill Store give my legal documents the professional look I want. There is no place local to buy such products anymore, but it does not matter because I can get products quickly and at a great price from this site.
5

3 years ago

review by Mary R.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

I received one box of envelopes and I am now ordering 2 more. The online ordering was easy. The delivery was fast, the price was good and the product is what I expected. Excellent business service. thank you.
5

3 years ago

review by Paula A.

#delivery(5/5) #price(5/5) #quality(5/5) #customer service(5/5) #on-time(5/5)

Thepapermillstore.com Review

Buy paper card stock envelopes more from top paper mills at The Paper Mill Store Save money with rewards discounts with free shipping available

Thepapermillstore.com Customer Service Contacts

No contact details for this company.

Sign in to write your review

You’re moments away from writing your review.

Sign in

or sign in with